NHL Picks

NY Islanders vs Columbus Blue Jackets Prediction 11/17/26 NHL Picks Today

Columbus Blue Jackets (7-11) vs. NY Islanders (9-6)
November 17, 2026 7:00 pm EDT
The Line: NY Islanders -142 / Columbus Blue Jackets +120; Over/Under: 5.5
(Get latest betting odds)

Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Prediction

Take the New York Islanders on the moneyline, as this matchup sets up as an ideal spot to back a home team catching its stride against a Columbus Blue Jackets squad that cannot string a complete sixty minutes together. Laying the price with New York on home ice makes complete sense when you examine how these two teams are playing right now. The Islanders have found ways to grind out results on the back end of their recent road trip, whereas Columbus continues to suffer from brutal inconsistency where their offense and defense take turns failing on a nightly basis, creating massive headaches for the coaching staff behind the bench while failing to find any predictable rhythm across forward lines or defensive pairings during critical stretches of games.

New York Islanders Recap

Matthew Schaefer anchors the New York attack from the blue line with a team-leading 21 points built on 6 goals and 15 assists, giving them elite production from the back end. Bo Horvat drives the forward group with a team-leading 9 goals alongside 11 assists for 20 points, while Brayden Schenn adds 16 points with 6 goals and 10 assists. Simon Holmstrom chips in 15 points featuring 9 goals, and Victor Eklund adds 11 points to give the Islanders solid secondary scoring depth that keeps pressure on opposing defenses throughout the contest. Furthermore, Matias Maccelli contributes 9 points despite playing only 10 games, while Jean-Gabriel Pageau, Emil Heineman, and Kyle Palmieri each chip in 8 points to round out a balanced forward group that wears opponents down over three periods. Anthony Duclair, Logan Stanley, Ondrej Palat, and Tony DeAngelo round out the supporting roster production with 5 points apiece, giving New York waves of capable players who can sustain pressure in the offensive zone shift after shift without ever letting up. Mitchell Chaffee also contributes 3 points in limited action to add further depth, alongside other depth pieces rounding out the roster.

Battle In The Crease

The real separator in this matchup sits squarely inside the crease, where Ilya Sorokin provides rock-solid stability for New York night in and night out. Sorokin carries a 7-4-2 record, a 2.53 goals-against average, and a .915 save percentage after turning aside 357 of 390 total shots, backed up by Semyon Varlamov who handles spot duty with 6 appearances. Contrast that reliable goaltending with the revolving door in Columbus, where Jet Greaves has struggled through a 2-8-0 record with a 3.42 goals-against average and an .875 save percentage on 265 shots. While Cam Talbot has given them decent numbers with a 5-3-0 record and a 2.51 goals-against average over 9 games, the defensive breakdowns in front of their goalies leave them constantly exposed to high-danger scoring chances and dangerous odd-man rushes.

Columbus Blue Jackets Recap

Columbus tries to generate momentum through Kent Johnson, who leads their skaters with 18 points on 8 goals and 10 assists, while Zach Werenski chips in 15 points from the defensive zone with 13 assists. Charlie Coyle adds 13 points on 3 goals and 10 assists, and Valeri Nichushkin contributes 10 points, but the Blue Jackets lack the overall roster depth to overcome their glaring defensive liabilities. Matthew Knies and Cole Sillinger each add 9 points, while Sean Monahan, Damon Severson, Adam Fantilli, and Denton Mateychuk chip in 7 points apiece, yet the collective group fails to find any defensive rhythm when the game gets physical. Mathieu Olivier chips in 6 points with 3 goals and 3 assists to provide some physical presence, while Dmitri Voronkov and Jake Christiansen chip in 4 points each, but the overall lack of defensive structure remains a glaring issue that opponents exploit easily night after night.

Chris Ruffolo's Free Pick: NY Islanders -142

Need More? Get Premium Picks

Chris Ruffolo

Chris joined the Sports Chat Place team in August 2016 and has a proven system that combines multiple analytical and situational statistics and trends to give out thousands of winning picks over the last three years with winning records across all of the top leagues, Follow Chris Ruffolo on Twitter @ruffthepickdawg

Related Articles

Back to top button